Ince its publication in 1913, charles beard's an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states has sparked controversy initially the book was denounced as an attack on the patriotic motives of the framers of the constitution in the next two decades the beard thesis settled into intellectual. This parcel of paperbacks on the beard thesis offers us the latest mixed fruit of a half-century of professionalization of the study of american history, newly packaged for the paperback resurrection we must surely welcome the reprint of beard's own economic interpretation of the constitution, which gives us the book as. In this, its centennial year, charles beard's 1913 an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states retains its hold on both the publication market and, at least in certain circles, the popular imagination its claim that the founders were possessive aristocrats out to protect the property of the. Get an answer for 'discuss beard's arguments in framing the constitution' and find homework help for other law and politics questions at enotes. As the title of chapter iv indicates, beard discussed here the significance of property qualifications for voting and officeholding as a protection for property, presumably meaning personal property, in the election of delegates to the constitutional convention since this involves the half of the beard thesis that american.
That beard offers to support his thesis first of all, he presents an analysis of historical records which suggests that a significant number of men at the constitutional convention and those dominating the ratification process had property interests that would be served by the new regime 1 robert e brown, charles beard and. Librarything review user review - patito-de-hule - librarything beard's 1913 history is a classic of historical revisionism the author puts down his thesis that the context of the constitution is to be found in economic phenomena it was a fad in all history at that time, and the book is now very dated read full review. In this famous study, the author turned the hagiography of many earlier american historians on its head unlike those writers, who had stressed idealistic impulses as factors determining the structure of the american government, beard questioned the founding fathers' motivations in drafting the constitution and viewed the. The debate over an economic interpretation of the constitution: where has beard taken us and where are we after mcguire's “new” interpretation my contention is that beard's classic thesis - that the contest over the american constitution reflected a conflict between economic interest groups that were.
Despite his negative conclusion, mcdonald still believes that an analysis of the economic background is important for an understanding of the origins of the constitution although he has not produced a full-fledged alternative to beard's thesis, he offers some suggestions toward a broader interpretation which includes. Charles beard's suggested that the constitution was a document that was only created to protect the framer's wealth beard believed that the reason why the rich framers wanted to protect against majority rule was to prevent the majority to overthrow the rich beard did manage to fit most of the framers under. Charles a beard presented seemingly irrefutable proof of the antidemocratic and conservative foundations of american national government in an economic interpretation of the constitution beard's thesis was that the politics of the 1780s were dominated by a deep-seated conflict between a popular party based on paper.
Charles beard argues that the constitution was written by a group of rich landholders who wanted to protect their property at the expense of the debtors and the poor farmers the slaveholding, landed class, he believed, was not motivated by philosophy rather, they were motived by their own economic self. 357) likewise concludes, “on all counts, then, beard's thesis is entirely incompatible with the facts” neither brown nor mcdonald, however, offered any modern rigor (no formal or statistical analysis of any type) in testing the behavior of the founding fathers during the drafting or ratification of the constitution yet brown and. An economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states charles beard selections 1913 full document in fact, the inquiry which follows is based upon the political science of james madison, the father of the constitution and later president of the union he had done so much to create this political science runs.
Since 1890 beard and the constitution: the history of an idea it is now more than thirty-five years since the first appearance of charles a beard's an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states the story of its reception and criticism is fa- miliar' a large part of its thesis has been absorbed into the main. The founders, beard conceded, did not write the constitution merely to make money, but nonetheless, “the constitution was essentially an economic document” beard's thesis, seemingly well researched, was presented in a tentative way, but it soon swept the historical profession and became gospel in. Charles a beard framing the constitution excerpted from charles beard's framing the constitution, in peter woll, ed american government: readings and cases, 11th ed (new york: harper collins, 1993) in the following essay, which is adapted from the supreme court and the constitution (1912), charles beard.